Voice of Stray Dogs, Data, Information, Analysis, Opinion ABC, ARV, Legal, Reports



info@strays.in


The Love of Animals and the Holiness of the Dog In Zoroastrianism – a letter to the Parsee/ Parsi side of Diana Bharucha of Stray Dog Free

Posted on | July 17, 2011 | 9 Comments

The Love of Animals and the Holiness of the Dog In Zoroastrianism – a letter to the Parsi side of Diana Bharucha of Stray Dog Free Bangalore (SDFB)

Written by Ms Persis Master, a Parsee on 16 July 2010 this is an open letter appealing to Ms Diana Bharucha (a fellow Parsee and the Convenor, Founder and the voice of Stray Dog Free Bangalore (SDFB)  [an organization vocally against any strays in the city of Bangalore and taking a a consistent exptreme view that strays and people can’t co-exist and all strays in Bangalore need to be culled]. Persis Master writes:

“A man who kills one shall abide in hell for nine generations” – Zoroaster

It is an interesting fact is that the first riots in Mumbai were by the Parsees in British India – when the British ordered the culling of street dogs of Mumbai! The Parsees first protested then rioted and the British agreed the dogs could stay.

Now I understand why Fali S Nariman defended the 3 lakh dogs ordered to be killed by the BMC at the Supreme Court and got a reprieve for them.

As a society, we can evolve only when we treat all living beings with respect and have a total absence of of double-standards. If the murder of a human is wrong, then, by any truly moral society’s standards, the murder of animals or any other being should be morally repugnant as well. We need to accept that animals are rightful inhabitants of this planet as well and we have to start living in harmony with them rather than without them.

Only when we realise and embrace our co-existence can peace – true peace come about. Any act of violence will only give rise to more violence and therefore, we must only choose humane, peaceful solutions to all our issues – jointly, sanely, peacefully and most importantly –
respectfully.

My purpose in this article is to show that that the love of dogs is an ancient, revered tradition of the original Iranians; an ancient virtue and a common Indo-European value that must be honored.

Ehtirám-i sag; or “great respect for the dog;” is a command among Zoroastrians. In Zoroastrianism, the dog is regarded as an especially
benevolent, and virtuous creature, which must be fed and lovingly taken care of. The dog is praised for loyalty, intelligence and having special spiritual virtues.

Dogs receive a striking degree of attention in the “legal” (dâtîc) books of the Avesta, notably in the “Vi-dêv-dâd” and the “Dvâsrôb” or the 16th Nask/Volume of the Avesta, the contents of which are known from Dênkart (q.v.) 8. Detailed prescriptions for the appropriate treatment of dogs are found in the Vi-dêv-dâd (one of the legal Avestan scriptures), especially in chapters 13, 14 and 15, where the faithful are required to assist dogs, both domestic and stray, in various ways. Help or harm to a dog is equated with help and harm to a human. Responsibility toward dogs is repeatedly linked with responsibility toward humans.

In the Hüspârâm Nask the proper quantities of food are listed for man, woman, child, and the three kinds of dogs (Dênkart 8.37.1).

In Vi-dêv-dâd 13.28 it is enjoined that a dog is to be given whole milk, hearty bread and other dairy products, staple articles of the diet of farmers.

In Sad-dar/hundred doors 31.1 it is enjoined that “whenever people eat, they should keep back three morsels from themselves and give
them to a dog or pet,” and this was general practice in the Irani and Parsi communities down into the present century (Boyce,
Stronghold, pp. 143, 145 n. 11). It is also a major sin if a man harms a dog by giving it bones that are too hard and become stuck in
its throat, or food that is too hot, so that it burns dog’s throat. Giving bad food to a dog is as bad as serving bad food to a righteous
human.

A sick dog or animal is to be looked after as carefully as a sick person (Vi-dêv-dâd. 13.35) A homeowner is required to take care of a
pregnant dog that lies near his/her home until the puppies are six months old (Vi-dêv-dâd. 15.45.) If the homeowner does not help the
dog and the puppies come to harm as a result, “he/she shall pay for it the penalty for wilful murder;” because the Spiritual Blaze/Fire
of GD watches over a pregnant dog as it does over a mortal woman” (Vi-dêv-dâd. 15.19.). The believers are required to take care of a
dog with a damaged sense of smell, to try to heal the dog, “in the same manner as they would do for one of the faithful.”

The killing of a dog is considered to lead to damnation and extreme evil luck.

According to Vi-dêv-dâd and in traditional Zoroastrian practice, dogs are allotted funerary rites analogous to humans. one of the places where
earth suffers most is where the bodies of men and dogs are buried (Vi-dêv-dâd. 3.8). If a dog dies in a house, fire/flame is to be taken out of that house, as when a human dies (Vi-dêv-dâd. 5.39-40), and the dog’s body is to be carried like a human to a place of exposure to the elements (Vi-dêv-dâd 8.14).

A dog’s gaze is considered to be purifying and to drive off daävás (demonic powers) and Nasü; the demon of rot, decay and nought. sag-did or literally “dog’s sight,” is a Persian/Zoroastrian term, and refers to a funeral practice in which a dog is brought into where the deceased is laid, so that the dog can “cast gaze” on the dead.

There are various spiritual benefits thought to be obtained by the ceremony. It is believed that the original purpose was to make certain that the person was really dead, since the dog’s more acute senses would be able to detect signs of life that a human might miss. A “four-eyed” dog, that is one with two spots on its forehead, is preferred for sag-did. The dog used for this task is ideally “brownish-golden with four eyes/two flecks of different-colored hairs just above the eyes; with golden ears” (zairit?m chathrü chashm?m, spaät?m zairi.gaösh?m; Vi-dêv-dâd. 8.16).

In Vi-dêv-dâd 19.30 two dogs are said to stand at the chinvat/illumination bridge, by the female figure of Daäná/insight, who there addressess the soul, and in Vi-dêv-dâd 13.9 these are called the “passage-protecting or p?šü.pâna dogs or spâna.”

In Zoroastrianism, dogs/pets are fed in commemoration of the deceased person. A portion of the food offerings for the deceased is always
given to a dog or pet (Boyce, Stronghold, pp. 143-44, 158; Modi, pp. 404, 350). During the three days after death, if there are no house
dog/pets, a stray is given food for the soul’s sake at every mealtime, and then, in Zoroastrian villages of Iran, once a day outside the house for the next thirty to forty days (Boyce, Stronghold, pp. 153 and n. 30, 158).

Being a Parsee means having respect for all those who live and share our space. A life is a life and needs to be respected.

Bibliography:

M. Boyce, Zoroastrianism. Its Antiquity and Constant Vigour, Columbia Iranian Series 7, Costa Mesa, Calif., 1992.

A. V. W. Jackson, Persia Past and Present, New York, 1909; repr. New York, 1975. A. V. W. Jackson, Persia Past and Present, New York, 1909; repr. New York, 1975.

Pahlavi Vendidâd, tr. B. T. Anklesaria, Bombay, 1949.

B. Schlerath, “Der Hund bei den Indo-germanen,” Paideuma 6, 1954, pp. 25-40.

 

 

 

Comments

9 Responses to “The Love of Animals and the Holiness of the Dog In Zoroastrianism – a letter to the Parsee/ Parsi side of Diana Bharucha of Stray Dog Free”

  1. smita
    July 17th, 2011 @ 6:26 pm

    This is quite well written and informative. Hopefully Diana Bharucha will appreciate this and work towards saving the lives of innocent dogs instead of preaching mindless slaughter.

  2. krish
    July 18th, 2011 @ 12:46 am

    They are not hungry anymore. “Voice of stray dogs” is getting louder.

  3. Nadir
    July 18th, 2011 @ 11:09 am

    Beautiful ways to life from a beautiful religion.I had no idea that dogs are given so much respect in the Parsi religion,very informative.Thanks

  4. Cherida Hivale
    July 18th, 2011 @ 11:39 am

    The unashamed violence of Mrs Bharucha’s intentions is shocking and terribly distasteful to say the least. And she’s a hypocrite to boot – doesn’t want to be perceived as a dog hater. We have to stop her murderous agenda.

  5. jolly singh
    July 18th, 2011 @ 1:15 pm

    if religious values haven’t redeemed her so far, maybe a mas protest will make her see sense. she seems to be living in a delusional world, trying to play god..play with the lives of helpless creatures.

  6. Freny Munshi
    July 18th, 2011 @ 2:42 pm

    Diana Bharucha please channel your energy positively and use your organisation to tackle the problem with other better alternatives like initiating a program of sterilising stray dogs and vacination program for stray dogs …. killing is definitly not the answer/ solution…… we all need to live and let live.

  7. K.J.ThanAWALLA
    July 19th, 2011 @ 11:09 am

    Stray should be nuetered but not culled.

  8. Archana
    July 19th, 2011 @ 1:35 pm

    Killing is not the answer. If it is, then I demand that beggars who create nuisance on the roads, homeless who encroach pavements, orphans who will become tomorrows prostitutes/thieves/murderers, physically and mentally challenged who are a burden to their own parents, drunkards who do nothing bu beat up their wives, HIV Positive…(the list is endless) should all be put to sleep or ”culled” as Miss.Diana says…

  9. Dinshaw patel
    July 21st, 2011 @ 10:39 pm

    Take care of the animals please

Leave a Reply





Donate Now


Rescue

VoSD Source of funds*


5% 95%
33.14 lakhs 628 lakhs
Donor funds Management Fund

Search VoSD CRM



VoSD Rescue quick STATS


Service available since: 2012-10-15
Days in Service: 1055
4964

Blood bank Quick Stats

Service available since: 2014-01-02
Days in Service: 611
41

CONTRIBUTE TO VoSD in INR

Recent Donors
  • Akshaya Manjunath


    Rs. 1500 Committed
  • Anand Rao


    Rs. 5000 Committed
  • SUZANNE JOHN


    Rs. 8000 Committed
  • Rheea  Mukherjee


    Rs. 4000 Committed
  • Lakshmishree Chakrabartee


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • kavya Nagesh


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Rupali Guha


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Rupali Guha


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Rajesh Gupta


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Vandana Rajendran


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Suzi Surface


    Rs. 10000 Committed
  • Kunal Gaurav


    Rs. 10000 Committed
  • nikita kumar


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • nikita kumar


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • nikita kumar


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Savitha vijay


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • savitha  vijay


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Santwana Tewary


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Madhumathi  Bhavani Shankar


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Sapna  Ramachandran


    Rs. 10000 Committed
  • Tulsi Shanmugm


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Sharath  SG


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Coco Mahajan Grandigae


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Pankaj Mehta


    Rs. 4000 Committed
  • Vinaya pradhan


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • manish khanna


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • MANISH KHANNA


    Rs. 1500 Committed
  • MANISH KHANNA


    Rs. 1501 Committed
  • Pallavi Shishodia


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Pallavi  Shishodia


    Rs. 4000 Committed
  • lokeshwari kuppuswamy


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Aditya Natarajan


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Sunitha Joseph


    Rs. 6000 Committed
  • Jisha George


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Sonnyaa Siingh


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Maria Theresa


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Sweata Dodka


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Jaipradha Devaraju


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Jaipradha Devaraju


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Taroon Bali


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Kavya Nagesh


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Snowy R


    Rs. 4000 Committed
  • Manish Manish Khanna


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Test test


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Test test


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Test test


    Rs. 100 Committed
  • Siddhartha Roy


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Siddhartha Roy


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Test test


    Rs. 100 Committed
  • Siddhartha  Roy


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Alluri Vijay


    Rs. 6000 Committed
  • Deepti Tilak


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Divya Rajiva


    Rs. 5000 Committed
  • Badriprasad Satyanarayana


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • nish nag


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • nish nag


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • NISCHITHA NAGARAJ


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • nischitha  nagaraj


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Temora Maclean


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Art by Aarohi


    Rs. 27000 Committed
  • JusTruffs Chocolatiers


    Rs. 2250 Committed
  • Save  Our Strays


    Rs. 10000 Committed
  • Save  Our Strays


    Rs. 10000 Committed
  • Aditi Gupta


    Rs. 10000 Committed
  • Hemanth Setty


    Rs. 6000 Committed
  • Smita Chimmanda


    Rs. 4000 Committed
  • Anjali  Sharma


    Rs. 25000 Committed
  • NANDINI  PRASAD


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Suchita Pande


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Season of Love Bake Sale


    Rs. 65000 Committed
  • Rakesh  Joshi


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Chetan Gurulingaiah


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Abhinandan  Roy


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Shrikanth Ramadas


    Rs. 5000 Committed
  • Deepak Devarajan


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Anjali Yadav


    Rs. 5000 Committed
  • Yasmin Matthan


    Rs. 10000 Committed
  • RAHUL KANDARI


    Rs. 500 Committed
  • Priyanka  Mukherjee


    Rs. 500 Committed
  • Priyanka  Mukherjee


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • vernika jhawar


    Rs. 500 Committed
  • Gaurav Srivastava


    Rs. 25000 Committed
  • Shruti Rajan


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Deepthi Prasanna


    Rs. 4000 Committed
  • Smita Banerjee


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Deepam Patel


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • MEERA MOHAN


    Rs. 500 Committed
  • Beena  Menon


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • satya prasad


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Chandra Kanta


    Rs. 500 Committed
  • Vidyasagar RM


    Rs. 1500 Committed
  • Shashi Buxani


    Rs. 2500 Committed
  • Manisha D Hegde


    Rs. 3000 Committed
  • Sunil Menon


    Rs. 5000 Committed
  • Hemamalini Sureshbabu


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Abbishek Rajhashekar


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Pramod Indiresh


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Shipra Trivedi


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Sudhir Mehndiratta


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Ankit Singh


    Rs. 500 Committed
  • Sudhir Mehndiratta


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • vijaya Shastry


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Devavrat Singh


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • maya p


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Vidyasagar Mysoremath


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Awanti Agarwal


    Rs. 1500 Committed
  • Sumeet Kumar


    Rs. 4000 Committed
  • Sudhir Mehndiratta


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Rosemary Samuel


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Home Bakers Guild


    Rs. 10000 Committed
  • Shashank Srinivasan


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Republic of Dogs Doggy Day Out


    Rs. 15000 Committed
  • Republic of Dogs Bake Sale


    Rs. 140000 Committed
  • Art by  Aarohi


    Rs. 31500 Committed
  • Neelesh Bhakta


    Rs. 10000 Committed
  • Yasmin Matthan


    Rs. 10000 Committed
  • Vanitha mahesh


    Rs. 4000 Committed
  • Rajat Shastri


    Rs. 3000 Committed
  • Deepashri C


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Nauzia Azmat Khan


    Rs. 5000 Committed
  • Dev Sanyal


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Anitha Rai


    Rs. 3000 Committed
  • Shweta Shalmali


    Rs. 4000 Committed
  • samantha  vrij


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Sinchan Mukhopadhyay


    Rs. 4000 Committed
  • Deepa Gowda


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Swathi K S


    Rs. 1500 Committed
  • Pavithra Gowda


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Pavni Guharoy


    Rs. 6000 Committed
  • Ketan  Gada


    Rs. 6000 Committed
  • Mamta Malhotra


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Ira Handa


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Indranil Dutta


    Rs. 10000 Committed
  • sowmya bv


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Sathishkumar Vijayakumar Pillai


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Sunny Shaw


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Vybhav Kumar


    Rs. 500 Committed
  • Srikant P


    Rs. 500 Committed
  • Divyarani Mruthyunjaya


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Prerna  Das


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Giselle Mehta


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Jubin Thomas


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Priya Prajina


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • SRIKAR DS


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • SIDHARTH SONI


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Sunayana Bansal


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • B Pavan Kumar


    Rs. 500 Committed
  • Srikant DS


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Estelle Vorster


    Rs. 10000 Committed
  • Krishnatriya  B


    Rs. 500 Committed
  • Joseph TI


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • SURESH A


    Rs. 500 Committed
  • Nandana S


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Deepa Gowda


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Roopali Sharma


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Vijay Anand


    Rs. 2500 Committed
  • Shankar Basappa


    Rs. 10000 Committed
  • Vikram Bhandari


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Samantha Gonsalves


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Deepthi Ajay


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Atreyee Deka


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Santak Das


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Taroon Bali


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Roopa Krishna


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • udit ujjwal


    Rs. 500 Committed
  • Anjali Sharma


    Rs. 20000 Committed
  • Sneha K


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Singh S


    Rs. 5000 Committed
  • Shreyita S


    Rs. 500 Committed
  • David Anthony


    Rs. 5000 Committed
  • Bhavesh Kumar


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Srikanta Raje Urs


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Rohit  R


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Anujit Mukhopadhyay


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Supriya Sanjay Shinde


    Rs. 100 Committed
  • Anoop A


    Rs. 5000 Committed
  • Devavrat Singh


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Arati Venkat


    Rs. 10000 Committed
  • Ramya Krishna


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Urvashi Subbaiah


    Rs. 10000 Committed
  • Nagarajan Viswanathan


    Rs. 101 Committed
  • Sampurna Rakshit


    Rs. 500 Committed
  • Swarnabha Ray


    Rs. 500 Committed
  • Rohit Srivastava


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Giselle Mehta


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Lalita Iyer


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Sanchita  Chakraborti


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Deepa Gowda


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Akanksha Pathak


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Anasuya Biswas


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Ketaki Indurkar


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Sudeshna  Sahu


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Anitha Rai


    Rs. 3000 Committed
  • Anindyo Chakraborty


    Rs. 6000 Committed
  • Archana MS


    Rs. 500 Committed
  • Manisha Nandy M


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Amrutha  Suresh Dani


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Mahesh Jayanna


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Sonali Banerji


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Shephali Gupta


    Rs. 10000 Committed
  • Sneha  Petnikota


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Kanika Mehra


    Rs. 3000 Committed
  • Kathyayani Shenoy


    Rs. 16000 Committed
  • Deepak Mayukha


    Rs. 10000 Committed
  • Dev Sanyal


    Rs. 2500 Committed
  • Karan Uthaiah


    Rs. 3000 Committed
  • Ashwini Pai


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Sheshadri BS


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Mayur Kashyap


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Arvind Prem Krishnan


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Aparajita Sood


    Rs. 7000 Committed
  • Anoop A


    Rs. 5000 Committed
  • Puneeth CN


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Jatin Rawal


    Rs. 500 Committed
  • Harsha Gowda


    Rs. 4000 Committed
  • Edna Sangeeta Thamboo


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Pooja Shastry


    Rs. 6000 Committed
  • Vijey Anand


    Rs. 3000 Committed
  • Ramya k


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Swaha Sircar


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Anil George


    Rs. 4000 Committed
  • Rohit Srivastava


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Akash Deep Sahrma


    Rs. 500 Committed
  • Karthik  Krishnan


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Harshita Sharma


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Anand Anand Rajamani


    Rs. 3000 Committed
  • Mayu Bhola


    Rs. 500 Committed
  • Anu Singh


    Rs. 4000 Committed
  • Shashi Buxani


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • mahesh kuntoji


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Suchitra Kumarachandran


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Poornima Ashoka


    Rs. 500 Committed
  • Deepthi Ajay


    Rs. 500 Committed