Voice of Stray Dogs, Data, Information, Analysis, Opinion ABC, ARV, Legal, Reports



info@strays.in


AWBI’s no AWO policy entrusts lives of dogs to municipal corporation employees with no idea of animal welfare or sensitivity towards animals or basic healthcare

Posted on | June 12, 2012 | No Comments

Over the last few months we have carried a series of articles on AWBI’s action in Kashmir that left out any Animal Welfare Organization (AWO) and went ahead with a tripartite MOU with SKUAST and SMC. Even the existing Kashmir SPCA was kept out of the picture.

MOU between AWBI and VBB for Vet Train Programme 2012 pg-1

Now it turns out that AWBI action in Kashmir is not isolated but seems like a well thought out approach of leaving out AWO’s from ABC implementation in India. This goes against the grain of the ABC (Dog Rules, 2001). This is strange since AWBI is entrusted with safeguarding the laws for animals.

  • There are now reports from ABC programs in Madurai and elsewhere that ‘AWBI has undertaken training of municipal corporation employees’ and this is being cited as the reason why these programs can/should run without any AWO.
  • AWBI and Vets Beyond Borders (VBB) have recently signed an agreement that leaves out all AWO involvement!

These moves are entrusting municipal corporation employees with low motivation, no idea of animal welfare, sensitivity towards animals or basic healthcare to deliver a service where malpractice or even inefficiency can cause great pain and death of animals. It is interesting that Municipal Corporations and the state and central government that are barely able to provide any recognizable healthcare to people should attempt to do it for dogs that can’t even protest. And even more interesting that AWBI should make this decision.

In this article we examine the question of the role of AWBI and the rules of ABC and is this what ABC was supposed to be?

The Animal Birth Control (Dogs) Rules, 2001 interpretation of Municipal involvement

ABC Rules provide as follows regarding animal birth control for street dogs :

Rule 3 Classification of dogs and their sterilization

  • Rule 3 (1)

All dogs shall be classified in one of the following two categories (i) pet dogs, (ii) street dogs
….

The street dogs shall be sterilized and immunized by participation of Animal Welfare Organizations, private individuals and the local authority.”

Rule 6 of the Animal Birth Control (Dogs) Rules, lists out the “Obligations of the local authority”.

  • Rule 6(2)

If the Municipal Corporation or the local authority thinks it expedient to control street dog population, it shall be incumbent upon them to sterilize and immunize street dogs with the participation of animal welfare organization, private individuals and the local authority.”

The obligation to control street dog population is therefore is therefore, clearly that of the Municipal Corporation or the local authority. The manner prescribed by the Rules is sterilization, i.e. through animal birth control. No other method is allowed.

Sterilization by whom and with whose participation?

The word used in the extracted sub-rules, i.e. 3(3) and 6(2) is AND, and not OR, i.e. the Municipal Corporation or the local authority has to sterilize and immunize street dogs with the participation of animal welfare organizations, private individuals, AND the local authority. (“Local authority” is defined under the Rules as being “a municipal committee, district board or other authority for the time being invested by law with the control and administration of any matters within a specified local area”.)

The Rules do not envisage that only the municipality, all by itself, embark on an animal birth control program. In fact, such an interpretation would go against the general tenor of the animal welfare laws. There are also many examples of animal birth controls programs going horribly wrong and terrible cruelties being perpetrated upon dogs, only because the municipality in question chose to embark upon animal birth control all by itself. The news that has recently surfaced from Madurai, of animal birth control by the Madurai municipal corporation, is one such example and also reflected in The Times of India

Training of municipal dog catchers and vets

Training municipal dog-catchers, and municipal vets is commendable, and required,  but can be no substitute for the “welfare of animals” perspective that an animal welfare organization is supposed to bring to bear upon animal birth control for dogs.

In any event, the law seems unequivocally to require the Municipal Corporation or the local authority sterilize and immunize street dogs with the participation of animal welfare organizations, private individuals, AND the local authority. The municipality CANNOT, all by itself, embark upon an animal birth control programme for dogs.

AWBI and VBB Agreement excludes AWO’s

So how is this interpretation reflected in the agreement that AWBI has entered in with Vets Beyond Borders for delivering training and equipping the ABC program under the aegis of AWBI? As in the case of Kashmir, the VBB MOU is clearly saying that AWBI, VBB and Municipalities will be doing ABC and completely excludes  the role of AWOs. The MOU also dangerously takes the role of the “authority” for training and certifying vets competent for ABC  thereby giving itself the mandate of the agency that can ‘license’ anyone to be vets to perform ABC.

A quick reading of the AWBI VBB MOU shows:

  1. No AWO/ NGO participation: There is no mention of NGOs, AWO’s or  private sector to be trained and it is envisaged that Municipal Corporations alone, trained by VBB with AWBI facilitation are sufficient to carry out ABC programs
  2. AWBI become executor: This runs contrary as AWBI’s mandate and has changed them from being facilitators to the certifying authority and executors. Surprising since a role they have painfully failed to discharge when any proactive legal intervention is required to be made – thence always claiming that the AWBI role is that of providing ‘guidance’
  3. New veterinary procedures in practice without the Vet Council: The MOU also shows that AWBI is now designing the veterinary practice procedures. Whereas the only body to mandate and design veterinary procedures is the Veterinary Council of India (VCI). There is no VCI involvement in this VBB-AWBI roll-out either.
  4. Illegal ‘Certification’ of vets by AWBI: The MOU ‘certifies’ the vets to carry out the ABC procedure. VBB is not approved/recognized by VCI to carry out procedures of ABC AR program which is an Indian state/ center run program only by limited agencies. Let alone given a mandate to legally train people. Both AWBI, VBB are legally incapable of doing training and executing on the ABC program. Vet-train graduates certified by VBB/AWBI do not qualify to participate directly in ABC AR. This seems to be a clear violation of VCI Act and ABC Rules, PCA Act. Through this ‘illegal’ certification AWBI is certifying a non professional – these don’t even need to be VCI licensed vets and can be anyone as per this MOU. In effect anyone can enroll for 2 weeks, get trained by a non certified vet from VBB and get certified by AWBI.
  5. Expansion of ABC’s scope by AWBI: Vide the MOU AWBI also seems to be expanding scope of ABC AR without legal procedures of court or parliament is amount to violation of PCA & ABC Rules.

With the interpretation of AWBI and its continued execution to exclude AWO’s and putting the mandate in the lap of Municipal Corporations AWBI could be doing its biggest disservice to the stray dogs of India yet!

Comments

Leave a Reply





VoSD Source of funds*


5% 95%
33.14 lakhs 628 lakhs
Donor funds Management Fund

Search VoSD CRM



VoSD Rescue quick STATS


Service available since: 2012-10-15
Days in Service: 995
4649

Blood bank Quick Stats

Service available since: 2014-01-02
Days in Service: 551
41

CONTRIBUTE TO VoSD in INR

Recent Donors
  • Akshaya Manjunath


    Rs. 1500 Committed
  • Anand Rao


    Rs. 5000 Committed
  • SUZANNE JOHN


    Rs. 8000 Committed
  • Rheea  Mukherjee


    Rs. 4000 Committed
  • Lakshmishree Chakrabartee


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • kavya Nagesh


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Rupali Guha


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Rupali Guha


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Rajesh Gupta


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Vandana Rajendran


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Suzi Surface


    Rs. 10000 Committed
  • Kunal Gaurav


    Rs. 10000 Committed
  • nikita kumar


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • nikita kumar


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • nikita kumar


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Savitha vijay


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • savitha  vijay


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Santwana Tewary


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Madhumathi  Bhavani Shankar


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Sapna  Ramachandran


    Rs. 10000 Committed
  • Tulsi Shanmugm


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Sharath  SG


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Coco Mahajan Grandigae


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Pankaj Mehta


    Rs. 4000 Committed
  • Vinaya pradhan


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • manish khanna


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • MANISH KHANNA


    Rs. 1500 Committed
  • MANISH KHANNA


    Rs. 1501 Committed
  • Pallavi Shishodia


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Pallavi  Shishodia


    Rs. 4000 Committed
  • lokeshwari kuppuswamy


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Aditya Natarajan


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Sunitha Joseph


    Rs. 6000 Committed
  • Jisha George


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Sonnyaa Siingh


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Maria Theresa


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Sweata Dodka


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Jaipradha Devaraju


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Jaipradha Devaraju


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Taroon Bali


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Kavya Nagesh


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Snowy R


    Rs. 4000 Committed
  • Manish Manish Khanna


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Test test


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Test test


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Test test


    Rs. 100 Committed
  • Siddhartha Roy


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Siddhartha Roy


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Test test


    Rs. 100 Committed
  • Siddhartha  Roy


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Alluri Vijay


    Rs. 6000 Committed
  • Deepti Tilak


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Divya Rajiva


    Rs. 5000 Committed
  • Badriprasad Satyanarayana


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • nish nag


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • nish nag


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • NISCHITHA NAGARAJ


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • nischitha  nagaraj


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Temora Maclean


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Art by Aarohi


    Rs. 27000 Committed
  • JusTruffs Chocolatiers


    Rs. 2250 Committed
  • Save  Our Strays


    Rs. 10000 Committed
  • Save  Our Strays


    Rs. 10000 Committed
  • Aditi Gupta


    Rs. 10000 Committed
  • Hemanth Setty


    Rs. 6000 Committed
  • Smita Chimmanda


    Rs. 4000 Committed
  • Anjali  Sharma


    Rs. 25000 Committed
  • NANDINI  PRASAD


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Suchita Pande


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Season of Love Bake Sale


    Rs. 65000 Committed
  • Rakesh  Joshi


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Chetan Gurulingaiah


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Abhinandan  Roy


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Shrikanth Ramadas


    Rs. 5000 Committed
  • Deepak Devarajan


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Anjali Yadav


    Rs. 5000 Committed
  • Yasmin Matthan


    Rs. 10000 Committed
  • RAHUL KANDARI


    Rs. 500 Committed
  • Priyanka  Mukherjee


    Rs. 500 Committed
  • Priyanka  Mukherjee


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • vernika jhawar


    Rs. 500 Committed
  • Gaurav Srivastava


    Rs. 25000 Committed
  • Shruti Rajan


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Deepthi Prasanna


    Rs. 4000 Committed
  • Smita Banerjee


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Deepam Patel


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • MEERA MOHAN


    Rs. 500 Committed
  • Beena  Menon


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • satya prasad


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Chandra Kanta


    Rs. 500 Committed
  • Vidyasagar RM


    Rs. 1500 Committed
  • Shashi Buxani


    Rs. 2500 Committed
  • Manisha D Hegde


    Rs. 3000 Committed
  • Sunil Menon


    Rs. 5000 Committed
  • Hemamalini Sureshbabu


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Abbishek Rajhashekar


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Pramod Indiresh


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Shipra Trivedi


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Sudhir Mehndiratta


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Ankit Singh


    Rs. 500 Committed
  • Sudhir Mehndiratta


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • vijaya Shastry


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Devavrat Singh


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • maya p


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Vidyasagar Mysoremath


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Awanti Agarwal


    Rs. 1500 Committed
  • Sumeet Kumar


    Rs. 4000 Committed
  • Sudhir Mehndiratta


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Rosemary Samuel


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Home Bakers Guild


    Rs. 10000 Committed
  • Shashank Srinivasan


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Republic of Dogs Doggy Day Out


    Rs. 15000 Committed
  • Republic of Dogs Bake Sale


    Rs. 140000 Committed
  • Art by  Aarohi


    Rs. 31500 Committed
  • Neelesh Bhakta


    Rs. 10000 Committed
  • Yasmin Matthan


    Rs. 10000 Committed
  • Vanitha mahesh


    Rs. 4000 Committed
  • Rajat Shastri


    Rs. 3000 Committed
  • Deepashri C


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Nauzia Azmat Khan


    Rs. 5000 Committed
  • Dev Sanyal


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Anitha Rai


    Rs. 3000 Committed
  • Shweta Shalmali


    Rs. 4000 Committed
  • samantha  vrij


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Sinchan Mukhopadhyay


    Rs. 4000 Committed
  • Deepa Gowda


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Swathi K S


    Rs. 1500 Committed
  • Pavithra Gowda


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Pavni Guharoy


    Rs. 6000 Committed
  • Ketan  Gada


    Rs. 6000 Committed
  • Mamta Malhotra


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Ira Handa


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Indranil Dutta


    Rs. 10000 Committed
  • sowmya bv


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Sathishkumar Vijayakumar Pillai


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Sunny Shaw


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Vybhav Kumar


    Rs. 500 Committed
  • Srikant P


    Rs. 500 Committed
  • Divyarani Mruthyunjaya


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Prerna  Das


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Giselle Mehta


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Jubin Thomas


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Priya Prajina


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • SRIKAR DS


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • SIDHARTH SONI


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Sunayana Bansal


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • B Pavan Kumar


    Rs. 500 Committed
  • Srikant DS


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Estelle Vorster


    Rs. 10000 Committed
  • Krishnatriya  B


    Rs. 500 Committed
  • Joseph TI


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • SURESH A


    Rs. 500 Committed
  • Nandana S


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Deepa Gowda


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Roopali Sharma


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Vijay Anand


    Rs. 2500 Committed
  • Shankar Basappa


    Rs. 10000 Committed
  • Vikram Bhandari


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Samantha Gonsalves


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Deepthi Ajay


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Atreyee Deka


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Santak Das


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Taroon Bali


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Roopa Krishna


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • udit ujjwal


    Rs. 500 Committed
  • Anjali Sharma


    Rs. 20000 Committed
  • Sneha K


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Singh S


    Rs. 5000 Committed
  • Shreyita S


    Rs. 500 Committed
  • David Anthony


    Rs. 5000 Committed
  • Bhavesh Kumar


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Srikanta Raje Urs


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Rohit  R


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Anujit Mukhopadhyay


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Supriya Sanjay Shinde


    Rs. 100 Committed
  • Anoop A


    Rs. 5000 Committed
  • Devavrat Singh


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Arati Venkat


    Rs. 10000 Committed
  • Ramya Krishna


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Urvashi Subbaiah


    Rs. 10000 Committed
  • Nagarajan Viswanathan


    Rs. 101 Committed
  • Sampurna Rakshit


    Rs. 500 Committed
  • Swarnabha Ray


    Rs. 500 Committed
  • Rohit Srivastava


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Giselle Mehta


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Lalita Iyer


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Sanchita  Chakraborti


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Deepa Gowda


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Akanksha Pathak


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Anasuya Biswas


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Ketaki Indurkar


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Sudeshna  Sahu


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Anitha Rai


    Rs. 3000 Committed
  • Anindyo Chakraborty


    Rs. 6000 Committed
  • Archana MS


    Rs. 500 Committed
  • Manisha Nandy M


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Amrutha  Suresh Dani


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Mahesh Jayanna


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Sonali Banerji


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Shephali Gupta


    Rs. 10000 Committed
  • Sneha  Petnikota


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Kanika Mehra


    Rs. 3000 Committed
  • Kathyayani Shenoy


    Rs. 16000 Committed
  • Deepak Mayukha


    Rs. 10000 Committed
  • Dev Sanyal


    Rs. 2500 Committed
  • Karan Uthaiah


    Rs. 3000 Committed
  • Ashwini Pai


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Sheshadri BS


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Mayur Kashyap


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Arvind Prem Krishnan


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Aparajita Sood


    Rs. 7000 Committed
  • Anoop A


    Rs. 5000 Committed
  • Puneeth CN


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Jatin Rawal


    Rs. 500 Committed
  • Harsha Gowda


    Rs. 4000 Committed
  • Edna Sangeeta Thamboo


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Pooja Shastry


    Rs. 6000 Committed
  • Vijey Anand


    Rs. 3000 Committed
  • Ramya k


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Swaha Sircar


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Anil George


    Rs. 4000 Committed
  • Rohit Srivastava


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Akash Deep Sahrma


    Rs. 500 Committed
  • Karthik  Krishnan


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Harshita Sharma


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Anand Anand Rajamani


    Rs. 3000 Committed
  • Mayu Bhola


    Rs. 500 Committed
  • Anu Singh


    Rs. 4000 Committed
  • Shashi Buxani


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • mahesh kuntoji


    Rs. 2000 Committed
  • Suchitra Kumarachandran


    Rs. 1000 Committed
  • Poornima Ashoka


    Rs. 500 Committed
  • Deepthi Ajay


    Rs. 500 Committed